Public Comment Period on New Servers 2

Xash

Tanehu98 isnt chemical exchange a very small pack? i remember chosen finishing it in 15ep or so , can we run it keeping long term bases in mind? (dont have much details on the pack so just asking 😛)

DoctorBlaze

I really like the idea of a space based pack, so I suggest AstroBlock or Planetary.

Keldroth

What about celestial Journey? The pack looks interesting.

Bheka

+1 to ATM5 if possible

Okavango

I would suggest RLCraft

Xash

Okavango i have tried rlcraft , its more of a vanilla pack with more mobs 🙁

Siezzo

I don't support the idea of an FTBR wipe, since me and 2 others join there regularly and another group of 2 also does. The servers has sometimes had 4-6 ppl on at the same time, while I've seen those some numbers on other servers too.
So could you please reevaluate wiping those servers? It would mean a lot for our group of 3 playing there as main modpack.

(I also find ATM3R generally a much more complete experience than ATM5 but opinions I guess, dunno why ATM3R has little players)

Siezzo

(About servers which are also low population, I'm talking in general about server such as PO3 and mce)

Tanehu98

po3 and MCE are under evaluations, po3 just got a reset and MCE has been seeing an increase lately. FR has been mostly dead lately, as has ATM3.
CE doesn't have a lot of mods in it, but is a skyblock with a lot to do despite that. Chosen tends to do like some of our member do and rush packs as fast as possible, but we are open to suggestions for other modpacks. We have been looking at skyblocks and kitchen sink packs, including slightly older ones.

The reason ATM5 has been concidered is because it is a 1.15 pack, and as of right now we don't have anything that up to date.

Siezzo

Tanehu98 We 3 have been quite busy with other things IRL but are planning to come back. Idk if 3 people online at multiple times of the week and sometimes perhaps 5 online is too little for FTBR, I at least know that mce and po3 also doesn't have much more than 3. That's why I'm asking to reevaluate this, we feel just ignored and cut off now that without warning, all our work in multiple weeks will just be wiped. Our giant trust in this modded network has diminished quite heavily now since all our work will get deleted while we didn't even know this network just suddenly decided things like this. We shouldn't have started with FTBR as modpack if we knew this kinds of things would happen...

Xash

https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/modpacks/minecraft-trillionaire

https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/modpacks/valhelsia-2

what do u guys think about these?

Tanehu98

Xash Yeah RLcraft seems to be a sort of 101 ways to die pack.

Tanehu98

Siezzo While we understand there are some player who play on these servers on occasion, we are seeing them being empty more often than not. That is why we are looking at replacing the, are there any packs you and your friends would be interested in playing as a replacement to them?

Tanehu98

Siezzo Your work won't be deleted, world downloads are provided anytime we reset or replace a server

Irgendwer

enigmatica 2 expert skyblock would be a good replace for FTB Revelations

Irgendwer

Irgendwer for all who wants to see it qhat for a pack is it
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/modpacks/enigmatica2expertskyblock

Xash

Irgendwer i like this skyblock idea 🙂 but seeing how e2e is popular even after reset and i agree with @Tanehu98 on not needing 2 e2e packs , i wonder how the community is gonna react if this big question is placed in front of them , i personally finished the pack one time so the skyblock version is gonna be quite a change , but might not for alot others 😛

Buffas

I like the idea of a 1.15 pack (ATM5), but as was mentioned above Celestial Journey seems to be a nice progression pack based on Divine Journey 1.7.10. So would be nice to try it aswell.
But if I need to choose from packs in the topic, my vote goes to ATM5.

Tanehu98

Buffas you don't have to choose from the packs in the message, we are simply considering those pack unless we get a lot of feedback for a different pack to replace them.

Tanehu98

I think replacing e2e with that would make more sense, we don't really need another e2e expert pack.

MeniMeni

I vote for ATM 5 and Chem Ex for now. In the future a TFC would be fun.
TFC Reloaded has a very active dev over the past 3-4 years.
https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/modpacks/terrafirmacraft-reloaded

Irgendwer

MeniMeni TFC reloaded is going to a rewrite it will be a long time when its done